Riding Magazine Q &A

April 2004: Pullback Problems

Question: “I’m at my wits end! My horse keeps pulling back breaking his halters and ropes. I can’t tie him to my trailer at shows and it is getting worse. No one knows what to do except to buy heavier halters and ropes, and to tie him tight to a big tree. I need your help.”

 Answer: That’s an excellent question.  I’m actually surprised that no one has raised this issue before. There are a lot of horses out there with pull-back problems, but few people seem to view it as a priority problem to fix.  Instead they just live with it and keep buying new equipment. Yet it is in fact a very dangerous situation for both the handler and the horse, not to mention expensive -- with the cost of replacement equipment and sometimes even vet bills.  The problem almost always gets worse on its own, and soon you find you cannot tie your horse to your trailer, hitching post, crossties, or anywhere else.  In fact it’s such a common occurrence that I am just starting to do a video about solving pull-back problems to be released in about two months.  

I didn’t need any convincing that it was a common problem, but my feelings were justified when we started looking for horses to be featured in the video.  We placed a notice about seeking horses with pull-back problems for the video on a local horse Internet chat board.  The response was amazing.  Within about 24 hours we had a couple of dozen people contact us with stories about their horses’ pull-back issues.  Many folks told us in the e-mails that while they would love their horse to lose the pull-back problem, they felt it just was not fixable, and as a consequence, was something that they had learned to live with.

 Don’t learn to live with it!  It’s very inconvenient and annoying for you as a horse owner not to be able to safely tie your horse but more important as I already mentioned, it’s dangerous!  Pull-back problems can absolutely be fixed. I have been dealing with pull-back horses for over twelve years and have been 100% successful in eliminating the issue.

.There are two reasons that horses pull back:

 1)  The horse has not learned to give to halter pressure. When it feels pressure on the poll, it panics and resists, which is pretty much a horse’s natural instinctive response.  Their survival instinct is their flight mechanism  - when they get scared to want to bolt. This is what we call their emotional button; all horses have it, but some far more than others. On a scale of one to ten, the average horse is around a five. But then some horses have a healthly dose of fearfulness which bring them to a ten or higher. In the olden days, and some people still do it, we would tie the horse hard and fast to a snubbing post and then did what we called sacking out. The horse would pull and pull but eventually would give up. This worked okay with the horses that had a naturally lower emotional level.  But those horses with a high emotional level/strong flight instinct, well they would continue to pull and flail about and usually finally broke what they were tied to and hurt themselves.

So as we have developed our methods as horse trainers in recent years, we have learned this is not a safe method or even a successful one. We want to set up the horse to succeed, not fail.

 The other reason that a horse pulls back is that it has learned to give to pressure but has become so frightened that the flight instinct overrode the cue. In response to these situations, we train the horse to learn to pull back in a specific way so that it can get relief (a way out) while still maintaining contact as the tie line is pulling backwards so it does not get release.

 Horses learn by pressure and release. Once a horse has broken a snap, line or halter, he gets that instant release. The next time a similar scenario happens where they may feel fear or restriction, they will keep pulling to find that instant release again. A conditioned response has been established and the horse has learned that it can get away.  To overcome this, the horse has to first learn to give to pressure, then learn to give to pressure when (highly) emotional. We do that through a series of exercises with a training tie and de-spooking work that will be covered in the video.  The process to fix the problem may only take 20 minutes (yep – it’s true) or may take a couple of weeks depending on how chronic the problem is. For example, horses that have actually broken gates or posts and ended up dragging them may take even longer. But no matter how chronic the problem is, we can fix this problem 100% of the time, saving you and your horse much anxiety and maybe even injury.